Boise State does not deserve a chance at the national title

By admin on Jan 11 2007 05:51 pm

People have noticed that Boise State is not included in my champion based playoff system, and rightly so. The WAC conference is nowhere near the caliber of the other 6 major conferences. Saying Boise State deserves a shot at Florida is like saying the Division II champion deserves a chance for the national title. If Boise State was good enough, they would have been ranked higher than Michigan or LSU and received one of the two at-large bids.


Vanderbilt could have gone undefeated playing Boise’s schedule; would Vanderbilt deserve a chance at a national title? The clear answer is no. Oklahoma is not the same Oklahoma from the past, and beating Hawaii does not constitute a chance at a national title.

2 Responses to “Boise State does not deserve a chance at the national title”

  1. on 25 Oct 2007 at 7:28 am Scott

    Saying boise st doesn’t deserve chance at the nat’l championship is like saying no teams from the super weak NL Central should get into the post season..but that’s where the 2006 world series champ came from. Same with the NFL…should teams from the weaker divisions not get their chance as well?

  2. on 28 Oct 2007 at 11:57 am bcsplayoffs

    I think a better analogy of comparing Boise State to weak NL Central team is comparing Boise State to a team in the minors. Just because a team goes undefeated in the minors doesn’t mean it can win the World Series. The WAC conference does not compare to the PAC-10 or SEC. Its more of a minor league.